Stop Overpaying for Automobile Insurance: Seven Strategies to Lower Your Auto Premiums
Automobile insurance has become one of the most frustrating expenses for American households. Premiums continue to climb, insurance companies regularly adjust their rates, and loyal customers often find themselves paying more simply because they have not challenged their current policy. The truth is simple: accepting your insurance company's renewal price without question is a costly mistake. If you want to lower your automobile insurance premiums, you must take an aggressive approach.
And before we continue, remember, auto insurance is a commodity, today. While auto insurance companies try to make you think they’re the best and have the best coverages – they’re all roughly the same. Now, some companies use the Family Auto Policy (FAP), others use a Personal Auto Policy (PAP), but at the end of the day, there’s virtually no difference in actual coverages. Coverages are standardized and virtually all insurers cover exactly the same perils.
Lastly, we ‘re only discussing non-commercial auto coverage – do not confuse this insurance with Business Auto Coverage (BAP). Those policies are significantly more complex and it’s not recommended to make changes without professional help.
First, stop being loyal to an insurance company that isn't loyal to your wallet. Most auto insurers provide a discounted rate for the first year you move your business to them. Unfortunately, at your first renewal, they hammer you with an outrageous price increase. Good news, you don’t have to be bullied.
Insurance companies compete aggressively for new customers, and you should use that competition to your advantage. Obtain quotes from at least five competing providers before renewing your policy. Tell your current insurer that you are shopping for better rates and give them an opportunity to match or beat a competitor's offer. Never assume your current company is giving you its best price – because after the first year - they aren’t.
Second, demand every discount available. Do not wait for your insurance agent to volunteer savings opportunities. Ask specifically about safe-driver discounts, multi-vehicle discounts, homeowners and renters insurance bundles, low-mileage discounts, defensive driving courses, vehicle safety equipment, and automatic payment incentives. Some discounts, like college alumni associations and good student discounts are not advertised or automatically applied, even when you qualify. Make the company explain which discounts you receive and which ones you are missing.
Third, challenge unnecessary coverage. Review every line of your policy and question whether you are paying for protection you no longer need. If you own an older vehicle (more than 10-years old) with a low market value, collision and comprehensive coverage will absolutely cost more than the financial benefit it provides. Drop these coverages. Compare the annual coverage cost with your vehicle's actual cash value (ACV).
However, never eliminate required coverages or protection you cannot afford to replace, such as uninsured/underinsured motorist coverages – especially in states like Virginia and Florida where upwards of 20% of drivers are uninsured. Nationally, the average is 15.4% of individuals driving without insurance. When adding underinsured drivers, approximately one in three drivers lack insurance or carries insufficient liability coverage to adequately cover certain accident-related injuries.
And don’t count on some ambulance chasing lawyer to help either – if a driver doesn’t have any or enough coverage, there’s not likely other assets to go after in litigation.
Fourth, increase your deductible strategically. Raising your deductible can significantly reduce premiums. If you have sufficient emergency savings, consider whether moving from a $500 deductible to a $1,000 deductible makes financial sense. Although do not select a deductible you cannot comfortably afford.
By the way, you’ll save more on a higher collision deductible (an at-fault accident where you damaged your property) than by raising a comprehensive deductible (named perils policies that cover your vehicle from not-at-fault claims – like fire, theft, weather claims, etc.). Comp claims are must less expensive to an insurer on average.
Fifth, use your driving habits to negotiate. If you work from home, drive fewer miles, or rarely use your vehicle, make sure your insurer knows. Ask about low-mileage programs and usage-based insurance. Safe driving behavior may qualify you for additional savings. Low mileage drivers can save upwards of 30% on premiums – but remember, you’ll have to prove your claim with a device that monitors your driving for a few weeks.
Sixth, challenge every unexplained rate increase. When your renewal notice arrives, demand an explanation. Ask what changed, whether your driving record was reviewed correctly, and whether your vehicle information and mileage are accurate. Correct errors immediately and request a revised quote.
Seventh, Never accept the first answer from an insurance representative. Ask for a supervisor, request a policy review, and compare competing offers. Be prepared to switch companies if another provider offers comparable coverage at a lower price. The GEICO Gecko is cool, as is Allstate’s Mr. Mayhem. But they aren’t cool enough for you to squander your hard-earned dollars.
The bottom line is this: automobile insurance is a business, not a loyalty program. Insurance companies are working to protect their profits. You should be working just as hard to protect your money. Shop aggressively, negotiate confidently, eliminate unnecessary expenses, and review your policy every six to twelve months. Stop automatically accepting higher premiums. Make insurance companies compete for your business.

